159 Comments

  1. How high are these layers supposed to rise? I have never leavened a cake with a vinegar baking soda mixture. I don’ think I overmixed but these layers did not rise very much and seem rather dense. The baking powder was brand new.

  2. I made this for Easter and it was a hit. I followed the directions exactly, except for one tiny thing: used the "wet" sugar method for making the caramel, which meant adding about 1/2 c. water to sugar before heating. Turned out great. That was the only way I'd ever made caramel, and I've ruined several batches in the past, so I wanted to use a method I'd used before. The cake is great; mine turned out pretty dense but still great texture and not too sweet, which is a great foil for the icing. I might bake it 1 or 2 minutes less next time, just to see what it's like. Icing was delicious, and of course, the CARAMEL. This recipe made a lot of caramel. I think you could halve it and be okay, but then you wouldn't have all that loveliness left over in the fridge. Divine. Thanks for a lovely recipe!!

  3. I made this cake a few weeks ago and everyone that tasted it said it was the BEST cake they had EVER had! I bake a lot and these people have tried lots of my cakes, always with great reviews, so that is really saying something!
    I'm going to visit my daughter this weekend at college and am thinking about making these as cupcakes! My plan is to "fill" the cupcakes with caramel sauce, and then pipe the icing on top. I loved the brown sugar/caramel icing but would like to make a firmer icing (for looks and travel). Do you have any ideas? I have made salted caramel icing before by simply adding a bit of caramel sauce to a half American buttercream/half cream cheese frosting. I may go that route. I would love to hear your thoughts.
    Thanks for the lovely recipe!!!

  4. Hi. I see that you don't update your blog too often. I know
    that writing content is time consuming and boring. But did you know that there is a tool that allows you to create new posts using existing
    content (from article directories or other pages from your niche)?
    And it does it very well. The new articles are unique and pass the copyscape
    test. You should try miftolo's tools

  5. Hi! I’m so excited to try this... I have a question- sorry if it’s dumb - but do I poke holes and soak all three layers? Or just the one? Don’t wanna overdo or underdo this cake!!

  6. Hi there ... about to make this cake and really looking forward to it. Reading the comments I notice a lot of people talk about how runny the icing is. I make cream cheese frosting a lot and actually swap the amounts of butter and cream cheese around - this makes it slightly less runny. The other thing people might be doing is buying own brand cream cheese - it is better to buy a good quality cream cheese. There is something about the chemical reaction of the cheese, butter and icing sugar that makes it really runny if you use the cheaper version of cream cheese ... not sure what it is, but having had my frosting refuse to thicken when I used the cheaper version once - never again!!! Thanks for the recipe.

  7. I made this but added about 1/2 tsp of caramel flavoring to batter. And, because a friend requested it with mocha frosting topped with coarse salt, I had to oblige. Spectacular! Thank you!

  8. Is there any reason why you couldn’t just use some of the left over caramel sauce in the icing, instead of making a new batch of caramel?

  9. I want to make this cake for Thanksgiving, but the problem is we do Thanksgiving in a mountain cabin with no real cooking tools. We get there on Monday, so I'm worried about it being fresh and transporting, so I was planning to make the layers and freeze them ahead of time. Do I go ahead and add caramel before I freeze, do you think? Or should I wait until I thaw? I know the caramel can be made ahead. What about the frosting? Do you think I can make it ahead and store it in frig in Tupperware?

    Thanks for any advice!

  10. Hi. I came across this cake and would love to make it for my son birthday but I am not very good with “cup’ sizes. Do you have the gram or oz equivalent please.

    1. Wait - you don't want to give me your email to to subscribe to get one of my most popular recipes FOR FREE... but you'll give me your email so that you can leave me a comment about how you don't want to give me your email? I too am glad you printed it out. Poof. Be gone. We don't need that negativity here. Byeeeeee.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *