67 Comments

  1. I think you need to add to the instructions that the batter must be completely cooled before baking. The batter was too runny and they fell terribly- I threw them out. I had made these before and they were fine but I think this was the problem. Needless to say there will be a baby shower at work tomorrow without cupcakes because of it.

    1. Actually - you don't need to cool the batter. I have made these with warm batter a hundred times, at least, and they come out perfect each time. I believe you may have not baked them long enough or overworked the batter.... that is the likely culprit for cupcakes that sink.

  2. Dear Betsy:

    I made the cupcakes and wish you had included a video, since I'm such a novice. I got stuck a couple of times (like how to strain the curd--I ended up with a batch with the seeds and then whatever went through the strainer and both tasted fine. So I wasn't sure how to do that or why I needed to do that. I ended up mixing the non-seed curd into the icing.) I also wasn't sure how to core the cupcakes....do you take out the cupcake and fill it with curd? Or put the curd in and put some of the cake back on top?
    My cupcakes also fell so that they looked pretty horrible, but I put the curd in the middle and then iced over them. I can send you a photo. I also felt that the icing was pretty stiff and it made a ton (2 pounds of sugar seems like a lot for the amount of liquid, so I'm sure I did something wrong.)

    My partner ate one of the fallen cupcakes and said they were delicious, so that's good. But I goofed on everything else! Thanks so much! I'm trying! 🙂

  3. These are my go to cupcakes! I loooove them!! Everytime I make them people freak out and want the recipe. The only change I make is doing a cream cheese frosting instead of buttercream (not a fan of buttercream). Otherwise, this is a god send recipe.

  4. Hello there,
    I just stumbled over this recipe while looking for something to bake for a baby shower.They just look sooo delicious and I'm curious to find out what they'll taste like. 🙂 And I'm especially looking forward to the raspberry curd. 😉
    Thanks in advance for sharing the recipe. 🙂

  5. These taste great, but mine fell in the middle. I am not sure if it was because my eggs were cold or because I over stirred the batter. I was able to cover it up with curd in the natural hole.
    I also wasn't sure how long to cook the curd. I needed to cook it longer than directed. Apparently, I need to cook it to 170 degree f.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *