19 Comments

  1. Betsy, your cookies look good. I love both lemon and chewy in a cookie. 🙂 I am going to give these a try. Can you give me some baking insight? I am trying to understand what makes a cookie chewy. I have found chewy recipes with corn starch, pudding mix (because of the corn starch), and brown sugar/molasses/honey. Any idea what ingredients help make these cookies chewy? Thanks! And my very best wishes for you and your husband on upcoming training and deployment.

    1. I'm not exactly sure of the science of it - but I do know that when I underbake cookies, they often have that crispy edge and chewy center I like. Personally, I believe it to be that it's still gooey cookie dough - not necessarily the ingredients. But, others have said that it has to do with the fat content. I don't know. I haven't done much research on it. Here's what America's Test Kitchen has to say: http://www.americastestkitchenfeed.com/bake-it-better/2012/03/secrets-to-thick-and-chewy-chocolate-chip-cookies/

  2. I made this recipe tonight, but I added a bit of lemon extract for a more lemony flavor. These cookies were so good, I was amazed! I had one question, in the recipe, at step 3, you say, "Add the brown sugar and butter and cream until smooth and fluffy." However, in the ingredients, there is no cream listed. I don't know if this is an error or if I'm not understanding it correctly. Could you help clarify? Thanks!

    1. In this instance, "cream" is a term used to describe the process of beating the sugar and butter together until they are smooth, creamy and fluffy. Sorry for any confusion! I'm glad they turned out yummy for you! Great idea adding the lemon extract to the batter!

  3. I have made these twice: for my daughter's wedding shower and for a weekend at the family cabin. Each time people raved. In fact, these are downright dangerous; my daughter has celiac disease (can't eat gluten) and kept sneaking these cookies anyway . . . and she's 33 and should know better! ; )

    Thanks for such a refreshing, unique and delicious recipe. I will be making them often, including today!

  4. I was looking for a recipe similar to the lemon cookies panera sells, and this is pretty close! I just dusted some powdered sugar on top and it was practically the same thing. Thank you for sharing this ????

  5. Made them tonight... decreased baking soda by 1/4 tsp because of elevation (6200 ft), chilled before baking, 10 mins at 350 plus those three minutes of cooling on the sheet... they are excellent! Thanks!

  6. Thank you for this recipe! Its Easter weekend and I've been wanting to make a dessert to go with dinner, these turned out great! Added a bit of lemon extract since i had it around and dusted powdered sugar on top after they cooled slightly. Better than Panera's!! 🙂

  7. These cookies are RIDICULOUSLY delicious! The batter itself was unbelievable. These are a new favorite. Wonderful recipe!

  8. These cookies were the perfect thing to make for our party. I made them a week in advance and froze them. They turned out great! Have to say they were a favorite at our party! Will be making them again soon.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *